Pride Of Detroit: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: The Boxing Bulletin for Boxing Fans!

Smith or Stafford...I'll tell you the right choice

Star-divide

Detroit Lions fans, keep your head up because fortunately for you, the only place you can go is up. Detroit hasn't been the best of places for football in recent years. Just think Matt Millen won't be drafting Joey Harrington at #3, or maybe a whole bunch of wide receivers when there are A LOT of glaring needs. The Lions have already been hitting with their offseason moves. The most important being the signing of head coach Jim Schwartz, who is going to bring a toughness and an edge to a team that has been lack luster in recent years. Peterson, Henry, Jackson and Buchanon bring a new look to a defense that allowed 30+ points, a record high, 11 times. The Lions have needs all over the field, and believe it or not, Schwartz knows this. He also knows that if he takes a quarterback and he fails, Schwartz just lost himself a career as a NFL head coach but if he takes a quarterback and he excels, he's a genius (ie, Mike Smith of the Falcons). Last year Tony Sparano and the Miami Dolphins knew of this situation and passed on QB Matt Ryan and took LT Jake Long.

This wasn't necessarily a bad move looking back at Ryan's rookie season but it helped both coaches in their first season tremendously. The Dolphins were able to get themselves a fine LT who will anchor their offensive line for the next decade and address their quarterback situation with a veteran QB and drafting a quarterback in the second round (Chad Henne, Long's teammate at Michigan)

For the Lions, first and foremost, there are very few people sold on Matthew Stafford and when your going to throw at least 72 million dollars over 6 years (which is what Matt Ryan got at the #3 pick in last years draft) as a management and coaching staff, you better be 100% sure that this is your guy. If not your team can be cash strapped for a few years and someone is going to lose their job. If your Matthew Stafford, you better be ready for all the big lights and criticism because every small, wrong move you make people will jump on you in an instant. Are the Lions going to take a risk at a quarterback with the #1 pick and if he fails then once again becoming the laughing stock of the NFL? I think the people in Detroit are tired of quarterbacks making bold predictions (Goodbye Jon Kitna) and want to win some games and turn around a franchise that has been pretty dismal as of late.

  Looking at the prospects who came in for visits; Stafford, Smith, Curry and Raji, who or what seems to be the most logical choice? If I'm the Lions at #1 I'm going to take Smith. ( I wont take Curry because thats way too much money for a linebacker that may only play two downs or Raji who can't keep his weight down). Why not? He is a big and athletic tackle who has experience at TE. Not only do you have Gosder Cherilus at right tackle but putting Jason Smith at left tackle gives you a pretty good outside of the offensive line. Although Dante Culpepper might not be the long term solution, he doesn't have to be. There was a time when he was a $100 million quarterback, and a sought after commodity in Minnesota. Those days are long gone but he still has enough in the tank to be a mediocre quarterback. If not, Jeff Garcia and Byron Leftwhich are still out there. If you need someone to come in and play well enough to win games you can get a veteran from the streets. Its better to risk it on a proven veteran than a rookie who is going to get a HUGE contract. Not to mention that there might or might not be a quality offensive lineman around at #20 but what if Mark Sanchez or Josh Freeman (who could be this years Joe Flacco) are still available? Do you wait 19 picks and draft a quarterback who may be as good or better than Stafford in the long run? Josh Freeman could possibly be a great pick at #20 if he plays well enough to win games and his contract will be much smaller than paying a quarterback at #1. Freeman or Sanchez could just be a possibility but if Schwartz has enough confidence in Drew Stanton it is a possibly he could be the #2 guy until the team is ready to draft a quarterback. I feel the Lions have too many needs to draft a quarterback #1. If he is a bust, the Lions have failed again and are the same old Lions. But, if the Lions go with the safe pick in Smith and don't draft a quarterback, who will have HIGH expectations to bring this team back from day one, they can develop the team to the point where they are a quarterback or one player away from being fielding a competitive team.

In addition to drafting a quarterback or bringing in a veteran free agent (which isn't likely), Jay Cutler still seems to be a strong possibility. The Lions have the most ammunition to trade to get Jay Cutler. I'm pretty sure if I were in the situation I would take Jay Cutler over any of the quarterbacks available in this years draft. The Lions might not even need to give up their #1 pick to attain Cutler. John Clayton previously said on ESPN Radio that the Lions seem to be the most logical choice in a Cutler trade. If I'm Jim Schwartz, I'm going to draft Smith at #1 and give my #20 and maybe another number two or whatever it takes to get Cutler in a Lions uniform. If the Lions have two first round offensive tackles, Kevin Smith, Calvin Johnson and Jay Cutler on offense with the additions on defense then this team CAN make little noise especially in the NFC North.  

So I end with this, the Detroit Lions have made significant moves this offseason for the betterment of their Franchise. I believe that they will keep going in this direction and with a few right moves in the next coming weeks, will have a legitimate shot at not being the same old Lions anymore. 

Poll
If you were the Lions and had to chose between these two players, who would you draft at the #1 overall spot?
QB Matthew Stafford Georgia
12 votes
OT Jason Smith Baylor
84 votes

96 votes | Poll has closed

This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of Pride of Detroit's main writer, Sean, or the site in general. FanPosts are valued expressions of opinion by passionate and knowledgeable fans.

1 recs  |  Comment 12 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Some good points.

Rant, Your comparison of the Atlanta and Miami 2008 strategies was very interesting. Everyone needs to remember that the Fins signed Pennington during the summer. So they passed on Ryan with Josh McCown as their nominal starter.

The other point I will make for the one-millionth time, it is DEFENCE that wins. In 2007, Miami had the #23 rated defence in the NFL. They were competitive in many games in 2007. Their absolutely horrible offence [all their RBs were hurt, QBs were terrible] caused them to lose the games that their defence kept them in. So in 2008, they got their RBs back [Brown and Williams] with an adequate QB, and their defence improved a little [to 15th rated] and they won.
The LIons in 2007 and 2008? Thirty-second [32nd] ranked defence both years. That was a huge comedown from their 28th ranking in 2006.
Her is Detroit’s Team Defensive Ranking over the years:
2002 – 31
2003 – 24
2004 – 22
2005 – 20
2006 – 28
2007 – 32
2008 – 32

People, we can’t win like this.

by NorthLeft12 on Mar 24, 2009 7:32 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Thats some UGLY defense ... !!!

 Maybe the Lions need to go ..
    LT — J.Smith ( then all defense )

by ralphgoblue on Mar 24, 2009 12:12 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Defense does Win

Championships for every sport but u still have to have an efficient OFFENSE to win…

by zeke313 on Mar 24, 2009 2:50 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

And your point is.........?

An efficient NFL offence is one that does not turnover the ball, can both run and pass, and scores around twenty-one points per game.
With a good defence, you can win with an average offence. The Lions have tried to build an offensive powerhouse for years. That has not got us very far. Lets try defence for a change.

by NorthLeft12 on Mar 24, 2009 4:55 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Defense is the point

Were not that far away form being an efficient offense, but D is a different story.

by zeke313 on Mar 24, 2009 7:53 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

I vote for ...neither one

Defense first. Take Curry at 1-1. ’Nuff said.

I has a blog

"A child of five would understand this. Send someone to fetch a child of five." ~Groucho Marx

by Jettero2112 on Mar 24, 2009 4:59 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Neither

Eugene Monroe is the better LT. I would love it if they went defense #1 (Raji or Curry)

by JazzyBBP on Mar 24, 2009 5:41 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Byron Leftwich

i think we should take Byron on the cheap, draft Smith, Curry is the best player in the draft but he’s too much cash for the position, Stafford is just way too risky for the money which most QB’s are unless you’ve killed some major college records and even then there’s a huge risk. Besides Byron was the MVP of the Motor City Bowl in 2000 and from where we (the Lions fans) sit that looks like pretty damn good credentials!!!! I think he’d be a steal i think the Steelers paid him just over 1/2 a mill last year. I’d sign him to a 3-5 year in a heart beat with some really good incentives in there. I guess i’m just rambling now, sorry haven’t been on in a few weeks. I’ll take Smith btw

by chainsaw on Mar 24, 2009 6:22 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Yeah i know.......

You have to read that with the same humor in mind i had when i wrote it!! The fact that he’s the only QB to win any kind of honor here since 2000 maybe we should bring him up to ford field and see how he does. 4 years 3.1 million loaded with incentives could bring something out of a guy who, in theory, should be in his prime years, i believe he’s 29, maybe he’s at that stage in his career where he wants to prove he’s not a career backup and his TD-INT ratio is better then Kitnas and a lot of other QB’s out there. This guy is a steal his value is higher then Dan O’s yet his cost is that of 42 year old sidelined running back. I just think we’d have nothing to lose by signing him and everything to gain.

by chainsaw on Mar 24, 2009 11:41 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Pride of Detroit, SB Nation's blog that is your source for everything Detroit Lions.
Start posting about the Lions »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Detroit-lions_small
Hint of Greatness?
Small
What a difference 2 weeks makes.....
Img_0883_small
November 22
Images_small
Am I just trying to find a silver lining or.....
66_small
Lions put Stephen Peterman on IR, sign WR Eric Fowler
Small
More Bad News
Detroit-lions_small
On Paper: Lions vs. Browns
Bubblesadjustment_small
Hearts out to Chris Spielman
Small
What if... ?
Awesome_small
This Should Cheer You Guys Up

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Pats Pulpit
Post Game Thread - Pats Over Jets 31-14
Cincy Jungle
Post-Game Thread: Cincinnati Bengals (7-3) 17 - Oakland Raiders 20 (3-7)
Gang Green Nation
R.I.P. 2009

Managing Editor

Pod_small Sean Yuille

Writer

New-lions-logo_1__small DrewsLions