I am actually completely torn on the two players because I think both would play their best ball in Detroit, Rogers because he absolutely loves the city of Detroit and playing for the Lions and Haynesworth because I think Jim Schwartz brings the best out of the big man.
Now they both have their downsides too, Rogers can hardly stay healthy anymore and can be kinda lazy at times, as for Haynesworth everyone and their mother has heard about him whining in the media about the coaching and system in Washington, also he can be lazy but I dont know if thats as much him trying to show up the coaching staff or what.
Honestly, I would probably take Haynesworth over Rogers simply because I think the upside is much bigger, and he has already been paid so much I think he will come pretty cheap for this talent level. But if Haynesworth doesnt wanna be possible a backup/spot starter, then I think Rogers would be happy to come home to his favorite Detroit strip clubs, I mean Lions.
What do you think?