DE position (thinner than it looks????)
Questions about D-line?????????
New to SB nation and POD, I wanted to post about something relevant and something everyone would have an opinion on. With the Saints recently signing Turk McBride, it can be said that it puts Detroit in a tough position. Even though I do believe the plan all along has been to resign Cliff Avril to a long term deal, I believe the Turk signing has given the advantage to Cliff not so much Mayhew, at the negotiation table. The question is, is a holdout on the horizon, (not familiar with where we are in the cap), but does Detroit have the funds at this time to even offer a long term deal? Part of me thinks they wanted to have him sign the one year deal so they could offer something better next year, as well as so they could address other defensive needs in this off-season. There is a reason Mayhew only offered the one year deal at this time. To me, he would have offered something more substantial initially if he wanted or could get the deal done. I believe even though the Turk signing seems like a small signing in national headlines, it has greater effect on the situation of the D-line in Detroit. I am not quite sure that I trust Young to step up at this point in his career a play an important back up roll. Everyone knows that we are set at the DT position, but is it time to trade, Williams or SLH, to find someone to help at DE. With KVB's injury last year as well as Avril not signing yet, should we worry about or DE position? I would like to think KVB will be the same as old, but neck injuries have ended careers before.
If Detroit was to move a DT, who do you think it would be? In this situation to me, Williams would be the logical decision. Even though very productive at times, it seems for every outstanding play, comes a 5 yard penalty. Not to say he is not great at getting the jump on the count, but at times it seems he has it in his mind he is going no matter what the case may be. I would love to keep all 4 DT on the roster, but do we have a bigger need at DE at this time?
It is funny because I do understand that Detroit has one of the deepest lines in the league. Thank to all for reading and the comments, hope it was an easy read. Also I want to say I think Detroit although not flashy did one of the best jobs in free agency. They focused on there needs, and came through with big signings in all need areas for great money. Well done Detroit!!!!!!
This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of Pride of Detroit or its writers. FanPosts are valued expressions of opinion by passionate and knowledgeable fans.
26 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I think we are fine
I like Turk, but honestly, basically everyone on the D-Line, with the exception of SLH, can play end…
I dont think we have anything to worry about, and that Big Willie Young will be fine when he is needed..
All men are created equal. Its just that some men are more equal than others....
by CapitolLions on Aug 1, 2011 9:20 AM EDT reply actions 1 recs
Word...
The whole line is versitile.
DE and DT is a blurr on this defense…. and rightly so…
….All I know is, Sir Toppumhat is not happy with Gunther Cunningham….

“YOU HAVE CAUSED CONFUSION AND DELAY…. NOW OFFENSES WILL NEVER SCORE!!!”
(sorry, I have been warped by my 5 year olds liking to Thomas the Train)
Lo-Jack is basicly a starter
meaing that Young will only need to come in when injurys or for a play or two a game.
Go check out the Datsyukian Deke , Detroit Red Wings Blog
http://datsyukiandeke.wordpress.com/
This is nice
Having a fanpost because we’re worried about how to fill our FOURTH defensive end spot…
House of Spears | My Detroit Lions/NFL Blog
HAHA.
WOW. good point. BUT…Wouldn’t Cam Jordon look goot in that spot? ha ;-)
Malek
by Matthew Malek on Aug 1, 2011 5:58 PM EDT up reply actions
We"ll be just fine
rollin with LoJack and Big Willie as the back-ups. Avril WILL be there. He’s not going to pay the 30K per day fine for holding out. Worst case Fairley could line up at DE in a emergency scenerio. Man thats scary, a line of
KVB Williams SUH Fairley
Durant Tulloch Levy
In that scenario I see Suh as an end.
He is quicker and possibly faster than Fairley.
Football isn't a contact sport; it's a collision sport. Dancing is a contact sport.--Vince Lombardi
Plus
there is always time for the Lions to trade for Osi Umenura of the Giants. He wants out, they approve his ability to look for a trade, and it will cost a first round pick.
Whatdaya think?
the only concern is the fact that Turk was definitely a role player personnel on this team. He brought it when he played and gave some much needed rest to the line however a lot of this Line is interchangeable as some have explained so i dont think it will affect the Lions much + this is the chance for them to see who/what else they have. Gun and Schwartz are masterminds on Defense and students as well as teachers of the game they’ll find a way to utilize what they do have not worry about what they dont.
A coward dies a thousands Deaths a soldier dies once ....
We are fine bud, this is the way I see it
If I was the coach, KVB would be starting on the RDE and LoJack would start on the LDE. IMO LoJack is actually better than Avril. I would basically rotate Cliff on on both RDE and LDE for snaps so that we essentially have 3 starting DE’s. Splitting the snaps much like it is planned to be with the DT’s.
Bust still after that we have Andre Fluellen and Willie Young who IMO can easily be rotational players as well. Flu is a very similar player to Turk if you ask me. While Turk has more leg drive and a bit better pass rush, Flu is very strong in his upper body and a bit more stout against the run. But the difference if you ask me is pretty minimal and I don’t see much drop off with him out there.
Willie Young is a bit of an enigma, the guy has gamer and play maker written all over him, and if I was a coach, which I am not, I would be finding a way to get this guy more snaps this year.
Personally, I like Avril a lot, and I would love to see him stay in Honolulu Blue for my own selfish, personal, emotional reasons. However the best thing for the team would be for another team to sign him and give us the pick on his tender. Barring that, even if we could trade him for a 2nd round pick I would be all over that. Hopefully Mayhew can work some magic and find some room on the cap for a long term deal with him, but if he leaves it is not exactly the worst thing for the Lions and might well be the best thing for them in the long haul.
Ndamukong Suh - Bringing 50's football back to Motown!
Cliff will be back
He’s been tendered with a first he’s not going anywere. I’m sure he will get his contract before next season. I’m not concerened I wanna see what grounds keeper willy has anyway. Now we get to.
"Power flows to the one who knows how. Desire alone is not enough." -MEGATRON
PCP 4 LIFE
Cliff will report on August 4th.
Between the 30K per day fine and the new rules about free agency and accrued league years he does not have the leverage you think he does.
Frankly, I am not very happy with Cliff. He knows damned well he is going to start camp on his tender offer. He should just sign it and get his ass to camp where he belongs. He may not be able to practice until Aug 4th but he could be there are part of the team and show where his head is at. Instead he is pissing and moaning about his contract.
When Avril was tendered at the first round level he immediately got a good raise. Avril’s base salary in 2010 was $470,000. Under his tender offer it would go up to $2,773,000. So even if he just signs the tender he is getting a about four times as much money as he was being paid on his rookie contract. So where is the problem here?
I don’t care what Avril is thinking. His holdout is a stark contrast to the attitude that is being displayed by everybody else on the team. He has put himself ahead of the team even though he has gotten a fair offer for a contract. I DON’T CARE if he cannot practice until August 4th. He could be learning any new wrinkles in the playbook, getting reconnected with his teammates, getting all the physicals and conditioning test out of the way, etc. There are things he could be getting done so that he is ready to go immediately on Aug 4th. Apparently he does not like being in that locker room as much as he likes working out by himself at home.
i kinda agree w/ you here Lynx
Right now i dont want to step on his toes but it sure shows thats the attitude he is taking on. At this time even the new FA are on the sidelines learning and getting to know their new mates this is important for chemistry and for a shortened off season its imperative in the direction that this team is headed that they all get together and get that chemistry and trust needed around them. He’s suppose to be a key player to this and should show he’s a leader as well. If not oh well maybe he’ll learn this season when LoJack takes his starting role …
A coward dies a thousands Deaths a soldier dies once ....
I agree, but...
It’s a business, on both sides. He has the right to to wait till the 4th to sign, to see if any team would make an offer. I doubt it will happen…but it’s his right, and I wont hold it against him. If he doesn’t show up on the 4th, then he’s being selfish imho.
Just livin' the dream...
Don't you think...
that if a player is sitting out of camp and waiting for an offer from another team, that means that they are not really committed to playing with the Lions? I think the $2.773 million from the tender offer is quite fair for this season. If he has three brain cells working for him then he knows that nobody is going to give up a first round pick for him. So if he is thinking that then he obviously overvalues himself, and that is a problem in itself.
On the flip side what is he accomplishing? I hate the idea that he is setting a tone for future holdouts by other players. If he would have signed and reported it would have put everybody in camp that really mattered. It would have set the tone that the team is all in for success. Instead he is setting the tone that he is all in for himself.
I hope KVB calls him
and tells him that his tender offer is fair and he needs to get his butt in camp.

by 




























