Lions Free Agents
I know, Sean already posted the list of Lions Free Agents as well as a brief breakdown of who he thinks will be back. Well, here are my thoughts on the Lions free agents and who should be re-signed.
Cliff Avril DE-UFA- I think the Lions will do everything they can to bring Avril back, but at the right price. While young pass rushing studs are in high demand and often bring the highest salary...it might be too much to keep him. He could go either way. I do expect him to be back with the Lions next year though
Jeff Backus OT-UFA- While Backus is getting long in the tooth and has dealt with some injuries the past few years, he still hasn't missed a game and has been playing some of his best football. I think the Lions will try to keep the vet around with a cap friendly 2 year deal so they can try and develop his eventual replacement.
Bobby Carpenter LB-UFA- While I love Carp, and I think the Lions like him, He has said that the Lions have made no contact with him or his agent about a new contract. I think the Lions will however re-evaluate their LB corp and realize that keeping Carp is the right answer. There is a 50/50 chance he wont be back though.
Erik Coleman S-UFA- Gone. I don't have any thing to really say about this. I was on the fence when they signed him...but I don't think they're going to keep him. I know he went on IR, but was he that spectacular before? Nope.
Rashied Davis WR-UFA I think that with his special team skills and willingness to do whatever is asked of him, the Lions keep Davis around.
Leonard Davis OT-UFA Gone. I think the Lions thought their OLine needed help and signed him before another team did. I think that with the return of Fox and hopefully Culbreath the Lions see two players that they can develop into solid starters.
Isaiah Ekejuiba LB-UFA- I think he'll be back. The Lions ST suffered greatly without him in there. I didn't think losing him would be that big of a deal, but he really is a great ST player.
Andre Fluellen DT-UFA This is another toss up. While I'd like to see him stay the Lions are pretty stacked at DLine. It's a toss up between him and SLH. I think SLH may have just a slight edge of Flu.
Ben Graham P-UFA FOR THE LOVE OF GOD KEEP HIM! I'm sorry. I do not like Ryan Donahue one bit. I think getting rid of Nick Harris for him was only smart from a salary aspect. From a skill and exp aspect it was dumb dumb dumb dumb. I think Graham will be gone, although I'd rather see him stay.
Chris Harris S-UFA- GTFU. I think the Lions were hoping that he would be the pro bowler he was a few years ago, instead they got CC Brown V 2.0. Gotta go.
Jerome Harrison RB-UFA Gone. The Lions tried to unload him during the season. While I wish him a healthy recovery from his surgery...I doubt he'll be back.
Shaun Hill QB-UFA I think Shaun Hill stays. I think he'll even sign a cap friendly contract to stay. He's already stated that he's happy here and that he'd rather be happy and a backup here then a starter and miserable some where else.
Sammie Hill DT-RFA This is the toss up between him and Flu. Like I said before, I think SLH edges out Flu even though I'd like to see them both stay.
Corey HIlliard OL-RFA I listed Corey as OL instead of OT because he can play multiple spots on the line. I think this is why they keep him.
DeAndry Levy LB-RFA I like Levy, I think his play slipped a little. I think with a full offseason for the LB unit to gel we could see a big improvement. He'll be tendered
Stefan Logan WR-UFA- Goodbye Little Man. I have a man crush on Logan. I think the dude is straight up awesome. However, I think with the change in rules he's been less effective. I would like to see the Lions keep him, but I think they let him walk.
Brandon McDonald CB-UFA- Gone. He's been in and out of the lineup. I think they MIGHT bring him back as a camp body, but I doubt he'll make the 53 in the end.
Maurice Morris RB-UFA I have no idea. He was slowed this year by injuries, but when he's healthy he's still a good back and a vet. I think it depends on FA and Best, LeShoure, and K-Smooth. would not surprise me if he's gone.
Don Muhlbach LS-UFA The continuity between a LS, holder, and kicker is very important. Look for them to bring him back.
Ashlee Palmer LB-RFA- I haven't seen enough out of him to know what to do with him He's a decent ST player but I haven't seen really much out of him as LBer. So, this one is a 50/50 to me.
Kevin Smith RB-UFA- Should he stay or should he go now? Injuries were the problem in the past, and look, injuries are still the problem. When he's healthy he's a beast...the problem is staying healthy. I think they bring him back for camp and see where it goes from there.
Drew Stanton -QB-UFA Stanton might be gone this time. I don't think he was on the game do roster at all this season. The Lions may look elsewhere.
Maurice Stovall WR-UFA- Maurice Stonehandvall will most likely be gone. Look for Detroit to pick up a cheap FA, a late round draft pick or an Undrafted Rookie Free Agent to take his place.
Donald Thomas OG-UFA Not sure here. He had promise at one point in his career. He's still young and he may be a player the Lions bring back to develop further.
Stephen Tulloch LB-UFA Bring back the little tank. This is pretty much a no brainer.
Derrick Williams WR-RFA- Didn't he retire?
Eric Wright CB-UFA-Bring this guy back. He played well (even though there were a few lapses) and I think more time in the system will only make him better.
Like it, hate it, indifferent to it....this is my take.
This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of Pride of Detroit or its writers. FanPosts are valued expressions of opinion by passionate and knowledgeable fans.
29 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I wonder
how everyone will be feeling come March and Avril has signed some big contract with the Falcons or the Cardinals.
I too think he will be back as a Lion, but if he gets the chance to test the market and someone throws 5 yr/$60 million at him I see him walking. If he hits the open market, he is a day 1 signing by some team.
I think Jeff Fisher might snatch up Avril for the Rams they have plenty of cap space.
We came! We saw! We lost to the Saints
The 2012 Lions will conquer
I think Jeff Fisher might snatch up Avril for the Rams they have plenty of cap space.
We came! We saw! We lost to the Saints
The 2012 Lions will conquer
I’d like to see them keep either Coleman or Harris unless we find someone else. We need a backup Safety.
SLH is much better then Fluellen.
MOMO is gone for Salary issues.
I’m not sure We can/should keep Avril. Hopefully he doesnt go too money Crazy.
Its scary how much of our Roster is up in the air at this point. I hope our team doesnt slip next year.
Out of Harris or Coleman
I think they’d keep Coleman. The only reason they even signed Harris was because they needed depth at safety…and after watching him play I think most people regretted the signing.
LITTLE MAN IN BACKFIELD! LITTLE MAN IN BACKFIELD! GO STEFAN LOGAN!
IMO
it’s a deep safety class. Draft one and kiss ’em both goodbye.
by Lionsickness on Jan 16, 2012 6:26 PM EST up reply actions
Yeah to be honest with you I cant remember Coleman that well.
Either one is fine with me. Basically a lower end starter type talent. I love Delmas but its becoming obvious to me that he is an injury case.
we dont need a backup safety, we need a starter and for spievey to move back
i liked the pick and i was in his corner, but down the stretch it seemed like he kept making errors that put him way out of position.
Unfortunately
I think SLH can do C. Will’s job at about 1/5 the cost so they need to bring him back and face the harsh reality that C. Will is way more cost than reward. Maybe draft a late round develop guy like Jean-Baptiste for depth if they want. Two first rounders and 5 mill for C. Will is just too much at DT when we have other needs.
Avril, Tulloch and Sammie will all be back I don't even see Flu as comeptition EVERYONE loves sammie
Eric Wright will get the houston treatment…Well can we do better ? I agree Levy will get a tender but with guys like Brandon Carr and other young outstanding corners hitting UFA I don’t see Wright as a lock. I don’t think he played THAT great. Morris is GONE book that and if you ask me Carp has showed some other teams what he can do. We might try to keep him but his career may have been given a boost to where other teams might look at him. Rashied Davis I agree he’s back but Stovall I’m not sure perhaps we see a vet like Donald Driver become availible or a late draft pick.
ROAR Offically Restored ! 12/24/11
THE PHONZ ~ I LOVE THAT GUY
PCP 4 LIFE
I don't think anyone will he's like 80 years old
But he can still be a productive roster member and a leader. I think we could see Titus as the number 2 and Nate as the 3 next year. Wouldn’t mind a guy like Driver being the 4th or 5th guy at a vetran minimum
ROAR Offically Restored ! 12/24/11
THE PHONZ ~ I LOVE THAT GUY
PCP 4 LIFE
by The Profiler on Jan 16, 2012 6:36 PM EST up reply actions
Agreed he would be a number 4
He doesnt’ play special teams though does he?
I’d rather get a late round speed receiver or pick up a guy cheap that can play special teams and maybe take Logan’s job.
No
But incase of an injury have to admit having him to fall back on would be nice
ROAR Offically Restored ! 12/24/11
THE PHONZ ~ I LOVE THAT GUY
PCP 4 LIFE
by The Profiler on Jan 16, 2012 7:26 PM EST up reply actions
Donald Thomas?
He is with the Patriots as I remember seeing him a few times in the Patriots lineup this season :)
I'm just going by the list Sean posted
LITTLE MAN IN BACKFIELD! LITTLE MAN IN BACKFIELD! GO STEFAN LOGAN!
Avril should go
If you look at the per snap numbers Avril is a little better in sacks than Lojack and Young is better than either. Lojack is far better than Avril against the run as well. The Lions are going to have to give Young and Lojack more snaps. It just doesn’t make sense to give Avril an all world contract, if you are going to have to cut back on his snaps. I like Avril, he would be wonderful as a solid rotational player in the line with his snaps reduced in half.
If that's the case...
maybe they should franchise him and then try and trade him.
LITTLE MAN IN BACKFIELD! LITTLE MAN IN BACKFIELD! GO STEFAN LOGAN!
Maybe but I'd hate to lose him
He’s going to have a lot less snaps this year because you can’t keep either Young or Lojack off the field. The problem with Avril leaving is that both Young and Lojack missed a considerable amount of play time due to one injury or another. If you’ve got Avril and KVB, as well, you’re in great shape. Avril down below 500 snaps would keep him fresher and allow the others to continue to develop. This really is a must because KVB is at the end of his playing days so these guys are the future DE’s. We can and should pay Avril good money but given a reduced roll in the future, we can’t do great money.
I always kind of thought
KVB would go and Avril would take his place. Then LoJack and Young would work the other side.
Please re-sign Avril, For the love of all that is good.
Honestly some people don’t realize how dire he is to our Defense! I trust our FO to do well in case we lose him, but I will lose Tulloch before Avril, pleeeeasssseee get him back.
"You simply cannot escape it. It's everywhere. There is a feeling the likes of which we haven't seen in decades. Emotions are high. Morale is climbing. People, once again, have something to talk about other than how disastrous our financial situation is and the collapsing of modern society." - Yahoo sports blogger.
+100000
I’ll kick Tulloch out myself if we get to keep Cliff
ROAR Offically Restored ! 12/24/11
THE PHONZ ~ I LOVE THAT GUY
PCP 4 LIFE
by The Profiler on Jan 17, 2012 9:42 PM EST up reply actions
afew players on the dfensive line will tacke apay cut sto help with the cap proleam to keep arvil on the team as for dt spot the younger players will start to play more so suh //hill //farley will get most of the snaps as for our cbs i think the lions will add one cb in fa and try to keep thier starters at cb if they cant keep them then they go get more fa or draft acb in the draft .will just have to wait and sea . as for mlb icant sea the lions not keeping tulioch un less hewants huge payday . also ithink backus will have to tacke pay cut or the lions might try fa thier our few fa that might be a upgrade in fa this year .
Nice post - like it
I think you evaluated players well and while I would love to keep Avril I too think somebody will throw ridiculous money at him. I am worried that KVB will need more rest and that we will be short in rotation if we lose Avril. I think that Bobby is pretty weak and pretty much a 53rd man on any team. We need to upgrade to a decent backup LB or two. How do we improve at corner as somebody could pay Eric Wright and who would we start the Fonz? We need some cap magic if we expect to sign some of the FA talent out there. I am a little worried but I have faith that Mayhew can improve the roster yet again. that is the name of the game, to keep getting better.

by 
























