Shoulder Surgery Behind Ndamukong Suh's Decrease In Production In 2011?
One of the most shocking things about Ndamukong Suh's outstanding rookie season was that he played through a shoulder injury that required surgery in the offseason. Suh didn't appear to be bothered by the injury one bit, as he made an impact throughout his rookie season and won numerous awards.
In his sophomore campaign, Suh's numbers dropped quite a bit. Suh still had a good enough season on the field to pull in some honors, such as being named to the Sporting News NFL All-Pro team, but his numbers were not nearly as impressive as they were in 2010. Why the drop-off? Warren Sapp thinks it was related to the shoulder surgery Suh had.
"The thing that affected him was he played such a power game, grabbing people and slinging them out of the way," Sapp said during an interview on Super Bowl Media Day. "He had rotator cuff surgery. I had one on each shoulder. I kind of know what that's like. You have to put yourself in a position where there was no offseason, no rehabbing and all the things he needed to do to be able to get that strength back. Now without that power, snatching and slinging people out of the way, he's never been a hip-flipper or a true pass rusher in a sense."
Sapp didn't hold back with his thoughts on Suh and blasted him for how he handled the stomp on Thanksgiving and everything that went on in the aftermath. Sapp also said that Suh needs to go into the offseason with the mindset of improving his pass rush game and "grind at the job."
Now, I don't think Suh's work ethic is the problem. Even when he was over in Europe for the Gumball 3000 workouts continued. Perhaps, however, with a full offseason with the Lions and there being no lockout, the workouts this year will work to get back whatever power Sapp believes has disappeared in the last year.
37 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Shoulder Surgey?....
More like double teams with excessive holding that was never called because he is “dirty”. People next to him need to step it up. Where is Cory Williams 10 sack season while Suh is sucking up double teams?
"I had to fight all my life to survive. They were all against me... but I beat the bastards and left them in the ditch."
Ty Cobb
It's not like Suh wasn't double-teamed last season.
Hell, in the Saints playoff game he was only doubled twice all game. Suh just needs to produce.
by Scout Taron on Feb 1, 2012 12:25 AM EST up reply actions 1 recs
C WIll was getting most of the double teams last season.
Charles Aaron "Bubba" Smith 1945 - 2011 R.I.P.
Oh really?
So you think that halfway through the season teams just started thinking. “Hmmm. Maybe we should double team the DT who has one sack as opposed to the one with 5”?
by Scout Taron on Feb 1, 2012 7:36 AM EST up reply actions 1 recs
It's true. Corey Williams was getting double-teamed more in the 1st half of last season.
Probably because he was a known quantity. Suh got a lot more attention as the season went on.
No slogans. Just win!!!
Also is why Suh had 6.5 sack in the first 8 games
3.5 the rest of the season.
Charles Aaron "Bubba" Smith 1945 - 2011 R.I.P.
Blaming the shoulder surgery seems counter-intuitive
Someone has to have game tapes from 2010 and 2011. Run them side by side and look for the difference. Seems like that could put an end to the speculation.
Formerly WestSideLionsFan. Fan of all Detroit sports teams.
Is it just me or does Warren Sapp's logic fail miserably?
He means to tell me that Suh put together a 10 sack rookie season while playing with a separated shoulder, yet managed just three with a fully healthy one? Something ASIDE from his shoulder wasn’t right in 11. Whatever it is, he needs to figure it out.
House of Spears | My Detroit Lions/NFL Blog
Follow @THouseOfSpears
I agree
and I suspect it was something north of the shoulder that was the problem. He’s a smart kid and I hope he’ll have a better grasp on reality next season. One thing I’ll say for Sapp that I found interesting, it’s the whole hip flicker concept. I never noticed Suh’s style of generating power tho but know a punch generated with the hips does a lot more than just with the arms/shoulders. Perhaps there is a little something to what Sapp was saying tho in if Suh’s shoulder didn’t set just right he was a bit “sapped” of power this year. It’s plausible anyway, likely? nah
Individuals should protect themselves. Governments can't protect individuals from themselves, it's just impossible, otherwise they become a tyranical state. -Ron Paul
Cant blame surgery
Teams were better prepared for him this year. You cant blame the shoulder surgery. He was constantly double and triple teamed as well as several holding calls on the offense that went uncalled. I think that is what lead him to his stomping. That and frustration. He will be back and better than ever next year.
So was Suh supposed to have 8-10 sacks the rest of his career???
How about we let the kid play one more full season before we start saying he needs to produce. It’s called the sophmore slump, alot of players go through it…
I believe Suh is talented enough
For 8-10 sack seasons every year. He is still young let him grow up some.
by hasselhoff on Feb 1, 2012 8:50 AM EST via mobile up reply actions
that's kinda what you hope for when you take a DT with the 2nd overall pick...
House of Spears | My Detroit Lions/NFL Blog
Follow @THouseOfSpears
Suh being double teamed
I think is an excuse. Jared Allen (douchebag) gets double teamed, and still manages to make plays. Suh even lost alot of 1on1 matchups.
Hopefully next year Suh comes back humble, focused, and much more mature, ready to play.
Now for the reasons for his drop in production is open for discussion. I believe its a few factors:
Lack of creativity with defensive schemes
Suh may have been injured
Cockiness; lack of maturity
Opposing coaches adjust to take Suh out of game
by hasselhoff on Feb 1, 2012 8:44 AM EST via mobile reply actions
I agree that there were probably many factors in play
I also think expectations are super high. People seem to think he should have the type of production that some top tier defensive ends have and that just is not the nature of the position.
There was a reason he tied the sack record last year for a rookie. It’s because that level of production is unusual and should not be expected year after year.
"My Mama once told me don't argue with fools, cause people from a distance can't tell who is who" - Jay Z
Allen is a DE
Which means he has a distinct advantage in lining up outside the OL formation
'The reality is - the police become necessary in human society, only at that junction in a society where it is split between those who have, and those who ain't got' - Omali Yeshitela
"In the absence of logic it is not uncommon that sanity can only be found by embracing lunacy." – Leonuro, circa 2011
i blame subway
5 dolla…….. 5 dolla…….. 5 dolla foot longgggggg any any
by redwingxviii on Feb 1, 2012 10:22 AM EST reply actions 1 recs
The surgery might have been part of it
I think losing those 15-20 pounds in the offseason hurt too, 285 is too small for a defensive tackle.
"There's something out there, beyond the horizon in the corner of your eye. I'm going to find out what it is."
-Thomas Solomon, Gentleman Adventurer.
Seeing as I got scolded for positing the same thought
I almost feel honor bound to holler at you for even proposing such an idea. Unfortunately, I agree completely with you, thus I will spare us both the silliness of a scolding
I think losing those 15-20 pounds in the offseason hurt too, 285 is too small for a defensive tackle
"Common Sense, isn't" Solomon Short
by YpsilantiJeff on Feb 1, 2012 2:02 PM EST up reply actions
I think you're *both* right!
No slogans. Just win!!!
Scheme
I think the biggest difference between year one and year two is that Suh played straight up almost the entire year this year because our defense had “improved”. In his rookie year he played DE and even LB on a few plays here and there. This led to increased counting stats like sacks(look at Thanksgiving sack of Brady). I think after all of the media scrutiny it would have been nice to set him up on the edge to make a couple plays but we had Avril, KVB, Jackson and Young rotating to perfection. Personally I think the right thing to do would be to sign Avril and then rotate Suh to DE every once in awhile this year while Fairley takes over at DT for those plays. Then in two years we should start Avril, Fairley, Williams/Hill, and then Suh at DE. At 285 he could be just as effective as Reggie White on the edge. KVB could be part of the backup rotation and still see plenty of snaps.
by dtowntigers4life on Feb 1, 2012 1:56 PM EST reply actions
Its all bullshit and "FILL"... Who can take the NFL network seriously anyway?
Hear you have a phenom as a rookie blowing up the stat book and making the probowl…. following that year… a lockout.
Bottom line is… Suh is a perfect example of how the Lockout can affect players… especially high profile players with a self promotional agenda.
Lack of coaching, lack of training on weaknesses, lack of position fundamentals and taking the game “to the next level”.
We can only hope that a structured offseason will include the creation of more “moves” and improved awareness for Suh. With this coaching staff, I have no doubt it will.
http://twitter.com/#!/rumbulls
**HERE WE** (EDIT)
http://twitter.com/#!/rumbulls
by CLF on Feb 1, 2012 3:10 PM EST up reply actions
suh had a great year his team made the playoff s in his 2year in nfl .did he have all sacks he had in his 1rst year no but his team didnot macke the playoff s in the 1year in the nfl . my piont is we should be glad the lions made theplayofflast year and add in the fact teams now have to game plan to stop suh and that is why the lions drafted farerly last year in the draft and you will be shocked at how manny sacks suhand farely wilhave next year when he has a full traing camp and ota next year and has a chance to be healthy and improve his game by being with the lions deffenve line coaches for a whole year where they will add some new moves to his game.
I hope you're right.
It might seem disturbing right now that his stats dropped, but I hope down the road in hindsight it won’t seem that significant.
It's turkey, Lions and Macy's. Any other combination is just ludicrous.
Twitter is for pussies. I follow people in real life.
"Ambition is a poor excuse for not having sense enough to be lazy." - Charlie McCarthy
Suh's rookie season he was not the focal point of opposing offensive lines game planning
in the first half of the season. He was an unknown rookie, so teams did not know what to aspect from him. Teams knew that Williams had back to back 7 sack seasons in Green Bay when they used a 4-3 scheme. Teams knew that KVB was back with his old DC from Tennessee where he had two double digit sack seasons. Teams knew that Cliff was a young talent that was getting better each season. That is also why Suh had 6.5 sacks in his first 8 games of the season, 3.5 sacks in the remaining eight.
Now, in 2011 teams knew about Suh, That is why he got the double and sometimes triple teams. That is also why KVB and Avril’s sack total increased this past season. The Lions sack total was 43 in 2010 and fell to 41 this season. Now much of a fall considering the Lions 2011 schedule. The Lions played against every NFC playoff team except for the Giants. Suh and the D-line are the reason why that the Packers and Bears spent a 1st round pick on O-linemen.
Charles Aaron "Bubba" Smith 1945 - 2011 R.I.P.
and to add...
He was named to the AP All-Pro team, voted on by NFL executives. Some of those guys have been around football, scouting and evaluating talent for 30+ years.
Charles Aaron "Bubba" Smith 1945 - 2011 R.I.P.
I am not
a stockholder of Sapp. I am a big fan of Suh. That said, I think 3 of Suh’s sacks last year came standing up. (Moving him around a good idea…check)
Suh definitely saw more double teams in year two than year one, he had less splash plays and got disqualified and suspended for a frustration foul. (needs to work on his game instead of his brand…..check)
pre-season Suh tweeted about benching 5 sets of 5 starting at 275 and ending at 350, if memory serves. (Shoulder problem….probably not; unless you think he was lying)
I am 200% on the Suh train and I am usually the first to defend him. However, if we see the same Suh next year that we saw this year, my opinion will start to change.
He can’t change how the coaches use him, but he can control how well he perfects his craft. With his physical gifts, he should beat enough double teams to avoid the frustration we saw.
the pros and the cons of the Lions
MLive in just one day has had articles that describe all the opinions of the multitudes of Lions fans.
Warren Sapp disses the Lions defense from Suh, the linebackers, and the defensive backs as well as Cunningham. Then Prime Time Deion Sanders really likes what he sees in the Lions progress from 0 – 16, citing injuries and the fact that the Lions are 2 – 3 dbs from being a solid defense. Plus with the Lions offense everyone knows points are going to be put up on the scoreboard.
Same logic with Suh, some Lions fans will proclaim from the mountaintops that Suh’s production went down in 2011, while across the valley from the other mountaintops some Lions fans will proclaim that Suh was double teamed, and there was way more opposing OL holding that held Suh’s numbers down. Some will fault Suh himself, the others will fault extenuating circumstances.
It is what it is, nothing is going to change from last year. The big question(s) and really the only important questions are looking forward are: 1) how are Mayhew and crew going to improve the Lions for next year. A nice start would be to resign Avril, sign CJ to a long term contract, would not hurt to get Tulloch resigned, then with free agency with what I suspect will be quality signing(s) as opposed to quantity of signings (read less free agents signed from other teams) and then the draft. And 2) how will Suh perform next year.
The only thing that remains a puzzle is Mayhew’s statement that he’s going to make trades, what does that mean? Draft day trades? Other trades?
Suh and Gunther's Defense
It’s not about Suh. It’s about a predictable defense that the rest of the NFL has figured out. The Lions cannot go forward with the scheme that Gunther Cunningham has developed. The Lions started 5-0 largely based on their defensive scheme. But the NFL is an elite league and after Kansas City exposed Gunther’s scheme (remember that the Lions defense was baffled in the first quarter) the rest of the league paid attention and made adjustments. Gunther did not make adjustments the rest of the season and kept trotting out the same scheme. When the Lions defensive played teams with equal or greater talent they got exposed. Contrast Cunningham’s approach vs. Scott Linehart’s. On the Offensive side Linehart made adjustments throughout the season. The Lions offensive evolved. Defensively they stayed in the same place and when they played equal or greater talent they were not successful. Gunther needs to change or be replaced.
It is not Gunny's defense
the wide 9 is Schwartz’s defense.
Charles Aaron "Bubba" Smith 1945 - 2011 R.I.P.
I believe 2010 Detroit Lions was Gunthers D. The 2011 Detroit Lions was Schwartz D.
Schwartz loves running that vanilla wide 9. Hopefully he learns from his mistakes and becomes a better coach.
I think Schwartz was better this year with managing time outs. If I was Schwartz I would have been working with Linehan and his predictable offense in the early part of the season.
I do believe if Linehan would have opened up that playbook earlier in the year, the Lions would have beaten the 49ers.
I hope Schwartz lets Gunny run more of the 2010 defense.
by hasselhoff on Feb 2, 2012 8:57 AM EST via mobile reply actions
One more thing that everyone forgot is that Suh played a lot fewer snaps than last year.
Last year, he was in on about > 90% of the defensive snaps, which was pretty ridiculous. This year, it was under 70%.
No slogans. Just win!!!
On the topic of Sapp, I think Coach Schwartz handled it nicely.
"Four sacks is nothing to sneeze at for a defensive tackle," Schwartz said. "Warren Sapp’s a great player. I think he had 12 sacks his first two years. Ndamukong had 14 his first two years."
Sapp’s retired. All he has to do now is talk, and I don’t give a fuck what he has to say.
Shit like this just has to push Suh to work much harder, you would think.
That goddamn Okra and beans got you Oprah in jeans. Seems to me a little lean cuisine, wouldn't hurt much- Agh don't touch! -Obie Trice
Discount Double Choke, 2011 Packers.
"Warren Sapp’s a great player. I think he had 12 sacks his first two years. Ndamukong had 14 his first two years."
Pretty much settles any arguments.
"You've got to respect your opponent, no matter who it is. You respect him best by going out there and beating him up." - Calvin Johnson
Listening to Warren Sapp talking about hard work and production
is about as funny to me as Jessica Simpson talking about tuna. The fact they give that man a microphone to wax poetic on work ethic boggles my mind. It’s like Michael Irvin getting down on a receiver for drug possession. Dude’s brain must still be coated with bong resin. I’ll listen to the comments if Howie Long or Michael Strahan have something to say about it. But Sapp? C’mon, man.
Lions, Huskers, & Wings
































