clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Wednesday open thread: Who has been the Lions’ best free-agent signing thus far?

The Lions made a splash in free agency this offseason; which contract has been the best bargain?

NFL: OCT 27 Giants at Lions Photo by Scott W. Grau/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

The Lions made headlines in March when they were (quite uncharacteristically of the Lions) one of the most active teams in free agency. They got some big names at the start, but also nabbed some players whose names flew under the radar. Thus far in the season there have been mixed results, but some names definitely stand out.

Question of the day: Who has been the Lions’ best free-agent signing thus far?

My answer: Marvin Hall Jr.

This one was close, and I was tempted to say Danny Amendola. Amendola had arguably his best game of the season thus far on Sunday against the New York Giants, and has been stellar in the run game to go alongside his 28 catches for 347 yards.

Given the Lions’ absolute failure in establishing some semblance of a reliable run game, however, I’ve gotta go with Marvin Hall. Hall is averaging over 40 yards per catch (!!!), currently standing at five catches for 201 yards. He may not make as much of an impact in the run game given his limited snap count, but he’s surely starting to draw attention from defenses.

This play in particular stood out to me on Sunday; if Hall got more than like two snaps per game I’d have gotten more film to make this point. Hall poses the threat of taking the top off of defenses, and defensive backs are noticing.

While this is in fact an impeccable throw by Stafford, it’s Marvin Hall who gives Golladay room to not get rocked as he makes the catch. With the Giants in a cover three look defensively, as soon as Hall breaks in on his post route the safety and corner are both blazing to the end zone hoping not to get beat over top. Expect defenses to continue to take note in future weeks; it should continue to open things up over the middle for Stafford.

While Amendola has pleasantly surprised this season, he also costs almost 10 times as much as Hall. Amendola signed a one-year contract worth $4.5 million, with the potential to reach close to $6 million with incentives. Hall, on the other hand, signed a two-year deal that lands him $690,000 each season. For that cost differential, Hall’s gotta be the best free agency signing of the offseason thus far.

Your turn.

Pride of Detroit Direct

Sign up now for a 7-day free trial of Pride of Detroit Direct, with exclusive updates from Jeremy Reisman on the ground at Allen Park, instant reactions after each game, and in-depth Lions analysis from film expert Jon Ledyard.