| # | Team | General Manager |
Player | Pos. | College | Approval |
| 1 | Carolina Panthers | Enforcer | Patrick Peterson | CB | LSU | 29% |
| 2 | Denver Broncos | CapitolLions | Von Miller | LB | Texas A&M | 53% |
| 3 | Buffalo Bills | CLF | Marcell Dareus | DT | Alabama | 76% |
| 4 | Cincinnati Bengals | SmittyJ | Nick Fairley | DT | Auburn | 55% |
| 5 | Arizona Cardinals | JazzyBBP | Blaine Gabbert | QB | Missouri | 82% |
| 6 | Cleveland Browns | latif | A.J. Green | WR | Georgia | 90% |
| 7 | San Francisco 49ers | JCruize | Da'Quan Bowers | DE | Clemson | 55% |
| 8 | Tennessee Titans | lionsfan_772 | Robert Quinn | DE | North Carolina | 72% |
| 9 | Dallas Cowboys | Jerry Mallory | Prince Amukamara | CB | Nebraska | 62% |
| 10 | Washington Redskins | Trysdor | Julio Jones | WR | Alabama | 82% |
| 11 | Houston Texans | Lead Hunter | Aldon Smith | DE/LB | Missouri | 75% |
| 12 | Minnesota Vikings | Ee Oulo | Christian Ponder | QB | Florida State | 32% |
| 13 | Detroit Lions | DrewsLions | Cameron Jordan | DE | California | 43% |
| 14 | St. Louis Rams | mgoblue4ever | J.J. Watt | DE | Wisconsin | 62% |
| 15 | Miami Dolphins | chucka | Mike Pouncey | OG/C | Florida | 54% |
| 16 | Jacksonville Jaguars | NorthLeft12 | Cam Newton | QB | Auburn | 62% |
| 17 | New England Patriots (From OAK) | Mavyrk | Tyron Smith | OT | USC | 70% |
| 18 | San Diego Chargers | sgdbw90 | Muhammad Wilkerson | DT | Temple | 48% |
| 19 | New York Giants | Elfuego51 | Corey Liuget | DT | Illinois | 48% |
| 20 |
Tampa Bay Buccaneers | lions_sucker | Adrian Clayborn | DE | Iowa | 74% |
| 21 |
Kansas City Chiefs |
Nate D. | Ryan Kerrigan | DE | Purdue | 78% |
| 22 |
Indianapolis Colts |
Lionsfan8 | Stephen Paea | DT | Oregon State | 57% |
| 23 |
Philadelphia Eagles |
n4ry4 | Jimmy Smith | CB | Colorado | 83% |
| 24 |
New Orleans Saints |
davis0169 | Brandon Harris | CB | Miami (FL) | 44% |
| 25 |
Seattle Seahawks |
Forty Handz | Aaron Williams | CB | Texas | 36% |
| 26 |
Baltimore Ravens |
TonyDC | Anthony Castonzo | OT | Boston College | 69% |
| 27 |
Atlanta Falcons |
ATL Lion | Justin Houston | DE/LB | Georgia | 66% |
| 28 | New England Patriots | Mavyrk | Akeem Ayers | LB | UCLA | 71% |
| 29 |
Chicago Bears |
The Profiler | Marvin Austin | DT | North Carolina | 54% |
| 30 | New York Jets | Joel Korson | Cam Heyward | DE/DT | Ohio State | 64% |
| 31 |
Pittsburgh Steelers |
BtotheLT | Derek Sherrod | OT | Mississippi State | 84% |
| 32 |
Green Bay Packers |
Gyorick | Nate Solder | OT | Colorado | 80% |
| # | Team | General Manager |
Player | Pos. | College | Approval |
| 33 | New England Patriots (From CAR) | Mavyrk | Mark Ingram | RB | Alabama | 81% |
| 34 | Buffalo Bills | CLF | Ryan Mallett | QB | Arkansas | 78% |
| 35 | Cincinnati Bengals | SmittyJ | Jake Locker | QB | Washington | 82% |
| 36 | Denver Broncos | CapitolLions | Phil Taylor | DT | Baylor | 75% |
| 37 | Cleveland Browns | latif | Bruce Carter | LB | North Carolina | 56% |
| 38 | Arizona Cardinals | JazzyBBP | Kyle Rudolph | TE | Notre Dame | 79% |
| 39 | Tennessee Titans | lionsfan_772 | Andy Dalton | QB | TCU | 75% |
| 40 | Dallas Cowboys | Jerry Mallory | Rahim Moore | S | UCLA | 81% |
| 41 | Washington Redskins | Trysdor | Gabe Carimi | OT | Wisconsin | 86% |
| 42 | Houston Texans | Lead Hunter | Ras-I Dowling | CB | Virginia | 66% |
| 43 | Minnesota Vikings | Ee Oulo | Ben Ijalana | OT | Villanova | 56% |
| 44 | Detroit Lions | DrewsLions | Davon House | CB | New Mexico State | 43% |
| 45 | San Francisco 49ers | JCruize | Brooks Reed | LB | Arizona | 68% |
| 46 | Denver Broncos (From MIA) | CapitolLions | Martez Wilson | LB | Illinois | 89% |
| 47 | St. Louis Rams | mgoblue4ever | Jonathan Baldwin | WR | Pittsburgh | 75% |
| 48 | Oakland Raiders | BBlades | Marcus Cannon | OT | TCU | 77% |
| 49 | Jacksonville Jaguars | NorthLeft12 | Jabaal Sheard | DE | Pittsburgh | 62% |
| 50 | San Diego Chargers | sgdbw90 | Randall Cobb | WR | Kentucky | 59% |
| 51 | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | lions_sucker | Curtis Brown | CB | Texas | 83% |
| 52 | New York Giants | Elfuego51 | Danny Watkins | OL | Baylor | 73% |
| 53 | Indianapolis Colts | Lionsfan8 | Stefen Wisniewski | OG/C | Penn State | 81% |
| 54 | Philadelphia Eagles | n4ry4 | Orlando Franklin | OT | Miami (FL) | 58% |
| 55 | Kansas City Chiefs | Nate D. | Leonard Hankerson | WR | Miami (FL) | 80% |
| 56 | New Orleans Saints | davis0169 | Mikel Leshoure | RB | Illinois | 72% |
| 57 | Seattle Seahawks | Forty Handz | Colin Kaepernick | QB | Nevada | 64% |
| 58 | Baltimore Ravens | TonyDC | Titus Young | WR | Boise State | 78% |
| 59 | Atlanta Falcons | ATL Lion | Torrey Smith | WR | Maryland | 77% |
| 60 | New England Patriots | Mavyrk | Jason Pinkston | OL | Pittsburgh | 54% |
| 61 | San Diego Chargers (From NYJ) | sgdbw90 | Sam Acho | DE/LB | Texas | 86% |
| 62 | Chicago Bears | The Profiler | James Carpenter | OL | Alabama | 66% |
| 63 | Pittsburgh Steelers | BtotheLT | Kenrick Ellis | DT | Hampton | 47% |
| 64 | Green Bay Packers | Gyorick | Jerrel Jernigan | WR | Troy | 61% |